I’m a Socialist. Wokeness Is Still the Left’s Biggest Liability.
By Meagan Day
Ms. Day is a senior editor at Jacobin.
A large and spirited class of freshman progressives is officially headed to Congress, including six democratic socialists and nine more candidates endorsed by Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont. Even moderate candidates won their midterm elections by talking about economic inequality and billionaires, suggesting the distinction between Democratic Party factions may be softening. The left has the best opportunity in decades to showcase its politics and values.
We can’t squander it. For nearly 20 years, I’ve watched one pattern pull the left off course after it takes power. It used to be called political correctness, then call-out culture, then cancel culture and now wokeness.
Over the summer, Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York tried to consign these excesses to the recent past, declaring that “Woke 1 was crazy.” But woke rhetoric has embedded itself into the party, and Democrats will have to work to excise it. Representative Ro Khanna of California celebrated the election results as heralding the return of D.E.I. Representative Hakeem Jeffries of New York, whom Democrats on Wednesday nominated to be the speaker of the House, dismissed a group of critics because they were mostly white. Leftist groups still find themselves divided over identity and privilege. And progressives have flooded the internet with jokes that “woke is back.” These posts may be kidding, but if our movement doesn’t distance itself from identity politics, we could jeopardize everything we’ve achieved.
To hear many conservatives define it, I would be considered woke. I’ve been a member of the Democratic Socialists of America for 10 years. I believe this country needs deep criminal justice and police reform. I am galled by ICE agents ethnically profiling and brutalizing people. I not only support gay marriage but am an enthusiastic participant in one.
But wokeness is not about a basic concern for social justice. It hyperfocuses on language and identity, fights dirty from the moral high ground and mandates deference to self-appointed spokespeople for marginalized groups. It conflates disagreement with harm, and keeps careful watch for heretics.
I’ve seen how it works up close. If the era between 2014 and 2024 is considered Woke 1, then I was around for Woke Beta, the soft launch.
When I arrived at Oberlin College in the fall of 2007, the student left’s center of gravity was shifting away from the antiglobalization politics of Gen X to something more millennial: the crusade against personal transgressions. We would make the world better by interrogating our privilege, purging our speech of microaggressions and alerting one another to missteps, sometimes viciously.
In one 2009 incident, a group of students threw a house party that caused a campuswide reckoning. The theme was, ill-advisedly, Mexico. A subsequent game of telephone spread the rumor that it was Mexican-themed, with rumors circulating that attendees had dressed as pregnant teens or migrant workers. The truth was not nearly so sensational. A few students may have donned sombreros, but even this was disputed at the time.
Still, the story took on a life of its own. A photo of women shaving their legs in the bathroom morphed into evidence that students were lathering themselves in self-tanner. A person who was said to have appeared in costume as a restaurant worker had actually, in a spirit of absurdism, come dressed as a French chef. After a huge student march on the quad and a hastily organized faculty panel, I came to suspect that people had eagerly misconstrued what had happened to showcase their rehearsed politics. And we were still a decade away from the cancellations and the identity politics of the late 2010s.
Wokeness’s vague, maximalist rhetoric trickled up to Congress. Moderate Democrats put on silly stunts to signal their “allyship” and co-opted woke terms like “feeling unsafe” to shut down protest. Leftists including Ms. Ocasio-Cortez and Representatives Rashida Tlaib of Michigan and Ilhan Omar of Minnesota echoed calls in 2020 to “defund the police,” an unpopular slogan that Ms. Ocasio-Cortez defended by tweeting that the “whole point of protesting is to make ppl uncomfortable.”
President Trump’s re-election quieted calls to defund and diversify. But wokeness persists today. In D.S.A., which I joined on the heels of the first Bernie Sanders presidential campaign, one still encounters debates about whether clapping is ableist or whether socialists should commit to “decolonizing ‘Minnesota.’” At its best, D.S.A. strikes me as our greatest shot at building a broad-based and politically serious organized left. At its worst, the energy reminds me of a scene from an Oberlin dining co-op, where a group of members filed in during a meal and silently unfurled a sign reading, “This co-op is messed up.” (They were protesting the privilege inherent in cliques; the sign’s wording was in fact less polite.)
The next Congress can’t let these debates trickle up again. The freshman representatives from the bluest districts, such as those in Brooklyn and Los Angeles, will still face pressure to spend their time denouncing offensive language and censuring members to their right. Instead, they should focus on making life better for working-class people — working toward Medicare for all, labor law reform, maybe even a Green New Deal. For the first time in a while, the moderate members of their party might actually be open to compromising on these issues.
As for wokeness, I suspect that many progressive elected officials are privately rankled by its excesses, but publicly inclined to ignore it, worried about inviting moral hectoring from the left. The most productive thing they can do now is grow a backbone. They need to take it upon themselves to elevate the best, most compelling ideas even when doing so earns them some pushback.
Take the issue of prisons and the police. I frequently talk to people on the left who lean toward what Paul Heideman, writing in Jacobin, has called carceral minimalism; rather than calling for abolishing the police or prisons, he has argued for prudently reducing the prison population while demanding thorough sentencing reform and improved corrections-officer training. But the conversation around ideas like Heideman’s has been sluggish, as anything short of calls for complete prison abolition has long been met with reflexive accusations of racism on the left.
This is exactly the kind of impulse we need to check going forward. Leftists: When you think a demand is unwise or a comparison is unfair, say so. Take hectoring on the chin. This forthrightness would go a long way to rebuilding a culture of open dialogue on the left.
I’ve seen a lot of wokeness in my time, and I’ve never seen it produce a sustainable, appealing and effective political formation. I have, on the other hand, seen the left make phenomenal advances by focusing on coherent, universalist, usually economic demands that unite people across differences and foster solidarity.
The American left can focus on meeting people’s material needs rather than scrutinizing their moral fallibility. But to get there, we must convey our actual opinions, not just the ones that keep us in good standing.